![]()
Most every generation has had an adaptation of A Christmas Carol to call their own. The classic Charles Dickens novella from 1843 has lived on in cinema through countless iterations starring the likes of Alastair Sim, Albert Finney, Michael Caine, George C. Scott; even the late Patrick Stewart once did a one-man-show playing every role. Newer generations have grown up with the wonderful Muppet Christmas Carol and the 2009 CG-animated Jim Carrey film directed by Robert Zemeckis. Yet, if we exclude the Bill Murray-starring Scrooged, there hasn’t been a notable live-action or non-Muppets adaptation since arguably the 1981 TV film starring George C. Scott. Genre filmmaker Ti West, known for his recent X trilogy, is taking a stab at the material in the form of a comeback vehicle for star Johnny Depp. Depp, whose reputation has taken a hit in recent years after his messy publicized trial with ex-wife Amber Heard, has found himself without a role in a major Hollywood film since 2018’s comatose Harry Potter prequel Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald. Despite the many troubling details of his personal life that have entered the public consciousness in recent times, Depp is still an actor with a passionate fan base and a movie star that audiences seem to be willing to give another chance to. Taking on the iconic role of scoundrel Ebenezer Scrooge makes sense for the actor given the meta-textual nature of the most famous redemption story ever written. Depp’s return to movie stardom makes for an entertaining and spooky take on Dickens’ classic tale, but the lack of heart prevents it from being truly noteworthy.

Courtesy Paramount
Director Ti West’s Ebenezer is a faithful adaptation of the classic story we all know and love, but with a hearty dosage of gothic horror thrown in. The House of the Devil and Pearl filmmaker’s retelling stays true to the beats of the original story, but amplifies the gloominess of 1800s England and the sense of macabre from Scrooge’s fateful night with three ghosts. West’s attempts at crafting this story within a gothic horror framework is indeed a valuable new touch, but the hollowness at the emotional center prevents Ebenezer from truly achieving its potential. Depp, whose performance is most closely modeled after Alastair Sim’s work in the 1951 A Christmas Carol, makes for a compelling enough Scrooge, but his performance lacks texture.
Depp’s performance is full of the eccentric mugging and theatrics audiences have come to expect from the actor in recent decades, but his take on Scrooge lacks the pain and sorrow that have made other portrayals on the character so iconic. Michael Caine and George C. Scott imbued such a stark sense of weariness and a soulfulness to their respective performances that’s all but lacking in Depp’s performance. Depp seems too eager to make Scrooge feel zany rather than tortured which makes the emotional beats feel stiff.

Courtesy Paramount
West is undeniably influenced by classic Hammer horror films, but he does succeed in giving this new adaptation a distinct sense of style. From the classic Paramount logo, to 70’s exploitation font in the opening credits and a well-utilized crash zoom, West’s sensibilities aim to give this adaptation a timeless, if exploitation-tinged, feel. The production design by Eve Stewart (The King’s Speech, The First Omen) is full of lavish sets and dreary, fog-drenched victorian streets. There’s a tactile sense of decay amidst the classically macabre setting. West doesn’t push the horror elements to the extreme, but he does enough to give the film a certain edge. Ian McKellen’s ghostly Jacob Marley appears bound in chains with an unhinged jaw so ghastly that even Scrooge pees himself. A small army of ghoulish ghosties chase after Scrooge and cry out for him to change his fate. There’s even a welcoming Nightmare on Elm Street homage with Scrooge being sucked into his bed just like Depp’s Glen character from Wes Craven’s original.
It’s what West does with his core ghosts that works the best, however. Andrea Riseborough’s Ghost of Christmas Past almost steals the film with her ethereal, otherworldly presence. Dressed in a decrepit wedding dress and saddled with blank white eyes, Riseborough’s performance adds a genuinely haunted touch to the picture. Tramell Tillman’s Ghost of Christmas Present is another highlight. Moving away from the jolly, larger-than-life figure of the source material, Tillman’s Ghost is far more sullen than we’ve seen in any previous iteration. West and screenwriter Nathaniel Halpern (FX’s Legion) even add an element of body horror to the character as he slowly deteriorates throughout his time with Scrooge. The remaining supporting cast is well-assembled with Rupert Grint bringing some much needed warmth and heart to the film as Bob Cratchit. Sam Claflin’s earnest portrayal of Scrooge’s nephew, Fred, also brings a level of emotion that pays off in the film’s final moments. Yet it’s frustrating to see an actor of Daisy Ridley’s talents be completely wasted here.

Courtesy Paramount
I’m not sure that Ti West is the person to best drive home the heart of Dickens’ classic story, but his style and darker, gothic sensibilities do add a layer of ingenuity to Ebenezer. West’s retelling of the classic Dickens tale is a diverting enough time at the movies, despite an uneven performance from star Johnny Depp. The film might not be a total lump of coal, but it likely won’t be anyone’s favorite present this Christmas season.
Ebenezer is now playing in theaters.
Leave A Comment