de facto film reviews 3 stars

After years of making acclaimed genre comedies, filmmaker Edgar Wright finally struck commercial gold with his fifth feature film, Baby Driver, earning both universal critical acclaim and over $200 million at the worldwide box office. With box office numbers finally able to match his cult and critical status, Wright has been given the reigns to make a properly-budgeted homage to the Italian Giallo films of the 60’s and 70’s. Full of slick, gorgeous visuals and a retro setting that suites Wright’s sensibilities perfectly, Last Night in Soho makes for another memorable addition to Wright’s oeuvre, even if it is his weakest film from a narrative standpoint.

Eloise (Thomasin Mackenzie) is a small-town girl with aspiration of becoming a fashion designer. After moving to the big city of London to attend college, the outcast Eloise begins to see visions of the past, transporting herself to the vibrant London scene of the 1960’s. Becoming more than just visions, Eloise starts following Sandie (Anya Taylor-Joy), a young starlet with dreams of becoming a nightclub singer. Sandie gets drawn into the scenic nightlife through the arms of a mysterious club owner, Jack (a snarling Matt Smith), where her devotion is quickly taken advantage of. Eloise’s reality quickly becomes intertwined with that of Sandie’s, leading to a decades long murder becoming a crime Eloise is determined to solve.

Using the Giallo genre forged by the likes of Dario Argento and, more prominently in Wright’s case, Mario Bava, to explore the repercussions of nostalgia, Edgar Wright sets aside his genre-bending skills for a more straightforward exercise. Despite shedding his more overt sense of wit, Wright maintains his cinematic charm, even if much of said charm comes from an animated, lively performance from Thomasin Mackenzie, who proves she can handle a leading role with grace. Whatever Last Night in Soho lacks in wit, it makes up for in pure, movie magic.

A more sleek-looking film as he’s ever made, Edgar Wright’s filmmaking is in top-form. Aided by striking cinematography from Chung-hoon Chung (Oldboy, It), Last Night in Soho fully immerses the viewer into 1960’s London with Wright’s signature kinetic visuals. The moment Eloise is taken through the streets of London and into a giant club, Wright’s sweeping camera flows through the space impeccably created with a realism rarely found in period-set studio films. A dazzling set piece set at a Halloween party features some of Wright’s most indelible imagery. An immensely educated student of cinema, Wright successfully takes his homages from films such as Blood and Black Lace and The Beyond and sidesteps the opportunity to make turn them into disposable nods, instead, baking such images into the narrative. The command Wright has over every frame is immaculate and a thrill to behold.

Serving as the soul of the film, Anya Taylor-Joy  radiates charisma off the screen. While the character may not be as rich on paper, the “Queen’s Gambit” star inhibits a soulfulness to the role and whose striking, lingering presence haunts the film. Her stunning A Capella rendition of “downtown” is one of the best sequences in the film, one that highlights just how exuberant the actor’s talent is.

While Edgar Wright’s visual panache has never been as accomplished or expressionistic, the writing is easily among his weakest material. The genre Wright and co-writer Krysty Wilson-Cairns are pulling from is known for its roughness, and Last Night in Soho comes across as toothless. Given most of the opportunities in the final act, there’s an awful lot of missed opportunities, or complete punches pulled. For as bloody and as twisted as Last Night in Soho can occasionally be, the film lacks bite. It’s primarily in the final act where things begin to truly fall apart. The scares are less, well, scary, and some less-than-convincing ghoulies that look right out of the classic Haunted Mansion ride feel plucked from a significantly lesser — and cheaper — film.

The late, Diana Rigg shines in her final performance as Eloise’s tenant and the ever-captivating Terrance Stamp adds some suave menace to his moments with Thomasin Mackenzie. However, if you’re going to pull from the works of Bava, Argento and De Palma, you can’t shy away from the aspects that make those works so influential and iconic.

Edgar Wright furthers his visual craft and delivers yet another entertaining thrill ride, but the emotional depth usually found in his last works is absent. Last Night in Soho is rich in production detail, memorable performances and slick direction, and despite the hollow emotional core, there’s a fun night out to be had.